Jacob

Edward is not a bad guy for a vampire, I don't hate him or anything. I just think that the right choice for Bella's long term happiness is Jacob.





Reasons I think that Bella should choose Jacob.





*He is warm.


*When he kisses her he thinks of real SEX and not just the possible food source flowing through her veins


*He would do anything for her.


*She can have children with him.


*His skin doesn't sparkle in the sun.


*They enjoy each others company in many satisfying ways, not just the heart racing blah blah blah.


*She doesn't have to give up who she is to be with him


*He may seem a little young and rough around the edges, but he's only 17. Edward has had hundreds of years to develop charm etc.


*Will Edward really love her when she is a vampire. It seems the things that he is enamored with are her scent (which will change when she becomes a vampire), her humaness, (which will also change) and his inability to read her thoughts (which makes her a mystery to him, will this change? We don't know).


*Edward is her first love. He is something between a teenage crush and hero worship.

* Jacob is loyal, giving, funny and strong. He can eat food, real food. And he's warm. And Bella feels good about herself when she's with him instead of feeling like she'll never measure up. And, and, and.